- Oct 7, 2025
Church Growth vs. Church Health
- Charles Bill Carpenter
- Church Growth
- 0 comments
Is Your Church Growing? (It’s Not Just About Attendance!)
Have you ever heard a church leader talk about how big their church is? They might say, "We had 500 people on Sunday!" That number is important, but it's like only looking at the speedometer in a car. It tells you how fast you're going, but not if the engine is healthy!
A church can have a lot of people, but if those people aren't becoming stronger followers of Jesus, the church isn't truly healthy. Transformation trumps attendance all day every day!
The Problem with Only Counting Heads
Imagine a church in a big city. People move in and out of the city all the time. This church might see 100 new people visit every year, but if 100 people also leave every year, the attendance number stays the same.
A church leader who only looks at the number "500" might think, "We are not growing!"
But maybe that church is doing a great job of quickly helping people find God and grow their faith before they move away! The church is healthy, even if the numbers don't change.
Every church is different. A church in a small, quiet town has to think differently than a church next to a busy university. The church must know its neighborhood to be a healthy servant to its people (Law of Service).
What Is a Healthy Church Engine?
Instead of only counting how many people come on Sunday, healthy church leaders look at other, better numbers. Think of these as the "health gauges" on the car's dashboard:
1. The Discipleship Gauge (Are people growing and are they growing others?)
Bad Number: How many people sit in the chairs on Sunday?
-
Better Number: How many people are in a small group, a Bible study, or serving others?
This measures the Law of Discipleship and Love. It shows if people are connecting and growing with Jesus and each other.
2. The Serving Gauge (Are people helping?)
Bad Number: How many programs does the church have?
-
Better Number: What percentage of the church members volunteer their time and talents to help the church or the community?
This measures the Law of Service and Dominion. Healthy Christians become helpers, not just happy listeners.
It is also critical to acknowledge not everyone serves in church sanctioned service. In fact a truly healthy church should include members that serve outside of church sanctioned activities.
3. The Life Change Gauge (Are lives changing?)
Bad Number: How much money did we collect last week?
-
Better Number: How many people have made a big life change—like getting baptized, stopping a bad habit, or starting to share their faith?
This measures the Law of Repentance (changing direction) and the Law of Truth. It shows if the teaching is making a real difference in their hearts and actions.
Instead of asking, "How many came?" start asking:
"How are lives changing right here in our neighborhood? Are we serving the people God put around us?"
When a church focuses on being healthy—on deepening the Faith, Love, and Service of its people—the growth will happen naturally. A healthy engine always goes further!
Knowing the Field: From Pew-Centric to Place-Centric Ministry
The moment a church shifts its focus from counting who walks in the door to understanding the world just outside the door, everything changes. The local church is not meant to be an exclusive club; it is an embassy of the Kingdom of God placed in a specific zip code to bring transformation. To fulfill this calling, leaders must become cultural anthropologists and community detectives. We must move past the general, comfortable assumptions about "the community" and dive into the specific reality of our immediate neighbors.
Analyzing the Contextual DNA: Geography, Culture, and Economy
Understanding the "field" involves studying the core DNA of your neighborhood. This goes beyond reading basic census data. It means understanding the Geography: Are you near a highway exit that brings in highly transient commuters, or are you in a tight-knit rural area where a family's history dictates their level of trust? It means decoding the Culture: Is the prevalent cultural mindset one of extreme independence and wealth (which creates its own kind of spiritual isolation), or is it one struggling with systemic poverty, family breakdown, and deep educational needs? Finally, leaders must grasp the Economy: What are the major employers? When the local factory shuts down, what immediate, tangible need does the church need to address? This crucial information reveals the real-life issues that people bring with them every Sunday—or, more importantly, the issues that keep them from ever showing up at all.
The Collective Response: Transformation, Not Just Transaction
When a church collects this data—when it truly knows its field—it stops offering ministry that is merely transactional (e.g., "Come get our sermon content") and starts offering ministry that is transformational. The church realizes its primary goal is not to have its own parking lot full, but to see its surrounding community flourish. If the local high school has a 50% drop-out rate, the church’s discipleship strategy may need to include a vigorous after-school tutoring program. If addiction is the prevalent challenge, the Law of Repentance is best preached through support groups and mentorship, not just from the pulpit. By weaving its spiritual mission into the socio-economic status and specific challenges of its geography, the church embodies the Laws of Righteousness and Service. The resulting growth is sustainable, deeply rooted, and a direct result of the Kingdom's impact on the ground.